Smart’s Head of Innovation, speaks at the Nobel Prize Summit

Smart helps lead the global conversation on technology, persuasion and deception

Smart

13/6/2023

Influencing more ethical and transparent practices within the technology industry
Computers, Privacy and Data Protection 2023 conference

The Nobel Prize Summit this year was at the National Academy of Sciences in Washington DC. Our very own Head of Innovation, Dr. Harry Brignull, gave a presentation about deceptive design at a solutions session, hosted by Transatlantic Consumer Dialogue and the Electronic Privacy Information Center, and the Minderoo Centre for Technology and Democracy, University of Cambridge.

During the same week, Harry also gave a presentation at CPDP2023 (Computers, Privacy and Data Protection) for a workshop titled “Deceptive Design In Online Interfaces And System Architecture: Questions For EU Law”. Here is an excerpt from Harry’s speech at CPDP:

“Voice assistants are going to be a sort of glue that connects together a lot of this new technology for consumers. I know they’ve been around for years – we’ve all got one of those hockey puck devices gathering dust somewhere at home – but so far they’ve been pretty dumb. That’s going to change. You’re going to have much better AI in them, and they will be an interface to everything else – to your home lighting, security, entertainment systems, and so on.

And the thing about these voice assistants is that they are much less neutral than web browsers. If you open up Firefox or Safari, you can access the entire web. The purpose is to put many businesses at your fingertips. Similarly, the job of a search engine is to connect you with those businesses and make some ad revenue along the way. It’s a very open market model.

With a voice assistant, if you ask a question, you usually want one good answer. Because voice is slow. It takes time to listen to the response. So you put your trust in it, and that’s abusable – because instead of giving the user options, the business probably will pick the answer that profits them most and it’ll respond with that.

So to summarise – voice assistants are going to get a lot more useful to consumers soon. They won't have to buy any new hardware. And they are not neutral technology – they very much lend themselves to a walled garden and that’s worrying.”

Smart is proud to be part of the global conversation about technology, persuasion and deception. By shedding light on the pitfalls of emerging technologies, we hope to influence the tech industry towards more ethical and transparent practices for the benefit of all users.

THIS IS JUST USED FOR RICH TEXT STYLING

The rich text element allows you to create and format headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, images, and video all in one place instead of having to add and format them individually. Just double-click and easily create content.

test for a pullquote here needs to be separate to test

Static and dynamic content editing

‍

A rich text element can be used with static or dynamic content. For static content, just drop it into any page and begin editing. For dynamic content, add a rich text field to any collection and then connect a rich text element to that field in the settings panel. Voila!

How to customize formatting for each rich text

Headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, figures, images, and figure captions can all be styled after a class is added to the rich text element using the "When inside of" nested selector system.

alkdhjda

Bullet 1
Bullet 2 aodj afhiahf iafhpioafh paofh oapfh aopfhaofh aofhaofh aofh aofhafo ahof haf

Bullet 1 apofdhjaof haopfhoap fhaopfh aofhaofh aofhaofhaofh aofhaofh
Bullet 2

‍

FOOTNOTES

CONTRIBUTORS

More from the Innovation team

Improving the information architecture of the Smart Pension member app

In this article we explain how we used tree testing to measure and improve the effectiveness of our information architecture

Making ‘Help’ helpful with search analytics

Harry Brignull presenting at the European Parliament on Dark Patterns

A few weeks ago I was invited to give a presentation at the EU Parliament, as part of an IMCO (Internal Market and Consumer Protection) committee public hearing

Pensions are boring, and that makes them fascinating

Scheme member engagement is an industry-wide problem – this article explains how the innovation team at Smart uses the B=MAP framework to facilitate behaviour change, and how it helped us create a successful “first time sign-in” feature

Animated pension walkthrough for Smart Pension scheme members

The innovation team showcases Smart's digital take on traditional annual pension statements - technology designed to enhance member engagement

Has cutting edge tech become a hygiene factor?

Technology is a given, what people really want is the choice and competition it brings, says Smart Pension’s Head of UX Innovation Harry Brignull during UK Fintech Week

See all Design and tech articles

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit.

News articles

Smart’s Head of Innovation, speaks at the Nobel Prize Summit

Smart helps lead the global conversation on technology, persuasion and deception

Smart

June 13, 2023

Influencing more ethical and transparent practices within the technology industry
Computers, Privacy and Data Protection 2023 conference

“Voice assistants are going to be a sort of glue that connects together a lot of this new technology for consumers. I know they’ve been around for years – we’ve all got one of those hockey puck devices gathering dust somewhere at home – but so far they’ve been pretty dumb. That’s going to change. You’re going to have much better AI in them, and they will be an interface to everything else – to your home lighting, security, entertainment systems, and so on.

And the thing about these voice assistants is that they are much less neutral than web browsers. If you open up Firefox or Safari, you can access the entire web. The purpose is to put many businesses at your fingertips. Similarly, the job of a search engine is to connect you with those businesses and make some ad revenue along the way. It’s a very open market model.

With a voice assistant, if you ask a question, you usually want one good answer. Because voice is slow. It takes time to listen to the response. So you put your trust in it, and that’s abusable – because instead of giving the user options, the business probably will pick the answer that profits them most and it’ll respond with that.

So to summarise – voice assistants are going to get a lot more useful to consumers soon. They won't have to buy any new hardware. And they are not neutral technology – they very much lend themselves to a walled garden and that’s worrying.”

About Smart

Smart is a global savings and investments technology platform provider. Its mission is to transform retirement, savings and financial wellbeing around the world.

Smart partners with governments and financial institutions (including insurers, asset managers, banks, financial advisers) to deliver retirement savings and income solutions that are digital, bespoke and cost efficient. In addition to the UK, Smart is operating in the USA, Europe, Australia and the Middle East with more than a million savers entrusting over £10 billion in assets on the platform.

Smart supports its clients with a global team.

Aquiline Capital Partners, Legal & General, Fidelity International Strategic Ventures, J.P. Morgan, the Link Group, Barclays, Natixis Investment Managers, DWS Group and Chrysalis Investments are all investors in Smart.

For media enquiries

Email: pressoffice@smartco

Smart’s Head of Innovation, speaks at the Nobel Prize Summit

THIS IS JUST USED FOR RICH TEXT STYLING

Static and dynamic content editing

Static and dynamic content editing

Static and dynamic content editing

Static and dynamic content editing

How to customize formatting for each rich text

FOOTNOTES

CONTRIBUTORS

More Design and tech articles

More from the Innovation team

Smart’s Head of Innovation, speaks at the Nobel Prize Summit

Smart helps lead the global conversation on technology, persuasion and deception

About Smart

For media enquiries

Search the site